Ron Coomer is an All-Star Hall of Fame: Catcher

With our player ranking system, we have determined that a score of 38 or higher will get you into our Hall of Fame or at least our fake Hall of Fame vote.  You don't have to score a 38 or higher, you can score close to it, we'll consider you.  With catcher, we multiplied the score by 1.2 because not only do we feel that WAR might underappreciate catcher defense, there is a high attrition rate for catchers.  We're trying to balance it out.  Without further ado, here is the first wing of the Hall of Fame, catchers.

Firmly in:(the numbers listed in the HOF score are already multiplied by 1.2)
1. Johnny Bench: HOF Score: 61.356. All-Star Seasons: 7. MVP Seasons: 1.
2. Gary Carter: HOF Score: 56.988.  All-Star Seasons: 8.  MVP Seasons: 1.
3. Yogi Berra: HOF Score: 49.944.  All-Star Seasons: 6.  MVP Seasons: 0.
4. Joe Torre: HOF Score: 47.496.  All-Star Seasons: 4.  MVP Seasons: 0.
5. Carlton Fisk: HOF Score: 47.412.  All-Star Seasons: 4.  MVP Seasons: 0.
6. Bill Dickey: HOF Score: 44.748.  All-Star Seasons: 5.  MVP Seasons: 0.
7. Mickey Cochrane: HOF Score: 44.316.  All-Star Seasons: 5. MVP Seasons: 0.
8. Ted Simmons: HOF Score: 42.996.  All-Star Seasons: 6.  MVP Seasons: 0.
9. Bill Freehan: HOF Score: 39.792.  All-Star Seasons: 4.  MVP Seasons: 0.
10. Roy Campanella: HOF Score: 39.564.  All-Star Seasons: 3.  MVP Seasons: 0.
11. Thurman Munson: HOF Score: 38.904.  All-Star Seasons: 3.  MVP Seasons: 0.

Willing to consider:

1. Gene Tenace: HOF Score: 37.98.  All-Star Seasons: 3.  MVP Seasons: 0.
2. Roger Bresnahan: HOF Score: 35.136.  All-Star Seasons: 3.  MVP Seasons: 0.
3. Gabby Hartnett: HOF Score: 34.512.  All-Star Seasons: 2.  MVP Seasons: 0.
4. Buck Ewing: HOF Score: 34.116.  All-Star Seasons: 1.  MVP Seasons: 0.
5. Darrell Porter: HOF Score: 32.688.  All-Star Seasons: 1.  MVP Seasons: 1.
6. Elston Howard: HOF Score: 32.22.  All-Star Seasons: 3.  MVP Seasons: 0.

Not yet eligible:
1. Mike Piazza: HOF Score: 55.14.  All-Star Seasons: 6.  MVP Seasons: 1.
2. Ivan Rodriguez: HOF Score: 49.584.  All-Star Seasons: 5.  MVP Seasons: 0.
3. Joe Mauer: HOF Score: 41.628.  All-Star Seasons: 4.  MVP Seasons: 0.
4. Jorge Posada: HOF Score: 37.74.  All-Star Seasons: 3.  MVP Seasons: 0.
5. Jason Kendall: HOF Score: 31.368.  All-Star Seasons: 1.  MVP Seasons: 0.